:: 講台討論區 ::

 找回密碼
 註冊
搜索
熱搜: 活動 交友 discuz
查看: 2827|回復: 1

Prometheus - Epic success .... in the history of stupid films

[複製鏈接]
發表於 2012-6-21 14:48:49 | 顯示全部樓層 |閱讀模式
A review of the film by  庫斯克 posted on IMDB:

Epic success.... in the history of stupid films, 7 June 2012
Author:
kursk1943

I don't know why Ridley Scott could approve such a stupid story. Nowadays, if scientists found a frozen ancient animal under the tundra, they will take precautions to prevent infection by ancient unknown micro-organism.

If you are the scientist in 2093, when you arrive at the first ever known E.T. structure in a strange planet, and you found there were breathable air, will you take off your helmet, provided that you know nothing about the biology of the planet?

OK, suppose you have taken off your helmet, when you see corpse of the alien life forms and the unknown vessels, would you think of putting back your helmet to prevent infection?

Suppose you are the poor geologist or biologist, why do you think you can leave the team and walk back to the entrance of the strange structure?

Suppose you are the biologist, when you see the first ever-know alive E.T. life form, which is a snake-like creature, why do you think it's vegetarian? Why do you try to touch it like touching Mickey Mouse in Disneyland?

Suppose you are the Weyland company's representative on the ship, why do you think your room and the surgery room need not be locked?

The story is so weak and stupid. It's weak in the sense that the audience need not worry about any further infection or invasion of alien at all, because the infected poor boyfriend dies so quickly, the baby alien is locked up so easily, and our dear Android David gave up doing experiments on his fellow team members so quickly.

Our dear archaeologist sweetheart (Noomi Rapace) even doesn't look like the main actress. She sounds like a tourist, even her boyfriend and several crews were killed. She did nothing to change the situation nor to prevent further tragedy. After her surgery, she simply followed the old man to visit the engineers.

The corporate iron lady (Charlize Theron)... well, I though she should do something at last. But she dies like a fool. That's all.

I waited for this story since I was a kid. I love the Alien movie so much. But what I watched is a story about a group of stupid scientist acts like tourists.
發表於 2012-6-21 18:02:36 | 顯示全部樓層
"a group of stupid scientist acts like tourists"

can't agree more.

不過睇故唔好駁故,君不見頭三集 Aliens 每次都只是死剩女主角一個,就知故事中的人類是幾咁白痴同無知。
如無意外,仲起碼有多一集故事。導演話這個個故事可以有三集拍。
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 註冊 |

本版積分規則

小黑屋|手機版|Archiver|talkonly.net

GMT+8, 2024-3-29 04:24 , Processed in 0.044032 second(s), 16 queries .

Powered by Discuz! X3.1

© 2001-2013 Comsenz Inc.

快速回復 返回頂部 返回列表